We all need to respect and honor the people who develop and operate public utilities. Our communities depend on the water and electricity that is delivered to our homes along with as the trash, recycling and wastewater that leave our homes. San Francisco is no exception.
The City’s “Hetch Hetchy Reservoir”, however, is overhyped – the result of a century of defensive marketing ever since it won the unprecedented Congressional battle to dam the glacier-carved valley inside Yosemite National Park.
The San Francisco Regional Water System is often called “Hetch Hetchy” even though it stores water in eight other reservoirs. City officials call it a “miracle of engineering” and describe the water as “pristine”. Restaurants in the City proudly list “Hetch Hetchy Water” on their menus, speciously claiming its taste is the best.
No other city applies such braggadocio to its water system. Let’s take a closer look at these claims:

Chief Engineer Michael Maurice “More Money” O’Shaughnessy points to a map of San Francisco’s watershed – what most us call “Yosemite.”
Engineering Marvel
It took 21 long years to provide water to San Francisco after the Raker Act was passed in 1913. Building Hetch Hetchy Reservoir and the conveyance system required a series of unplanned and unwelcome bond issues; the project’s Chief Engineer, Michael Maurice O’Shaughnessy, was nicknamed “More Money O’Shaughnessy” in the press.
Sadly, some 89 workers died during the project’s construction, including twelve who were killed in a methane explosion when the Coast Range Tunnel was being drilled.
By contrast, it took only 3 years for the East Bay Municipal Utilities District to complete Pardee Reservoir and its Mokelumne Aqueduct to deliver water to Berkeley, Oakland and other cities across the Bay. (San Francisco had invited the east bay cities to invest with them but the offer was declined.)
So it’s absurd to call Hetch Hetchy an engineering marvel due to the project’s costs of money, time and human life.
Pristine Water
San Francisco boasts that it does not need to filter supplies coming directly from Hetch Hetchy Reservoir. The lack of filtration does not mean the water is any safer or better tasting (see below); rather it saves money that other cities routinely pay to treat their water. As a result, park visitors in Yosemite cannot paddle a canoe or kayak on the reservoir – activities that would greatly expand access for fishing, side hikes and rock climbing as well as provide views of the extraordinary canyon.
When Congress debated the construction of the dam in Yosemite National Park, representatives, including the bill’s namesake John Raker of Manteca, assumed boating would be allowed and indeed popular. Just after the reservoir was completed, Superintendent Horace Albright hired a concessionaire to provide boat rides only to be stopped cold by San Francisco. Today – the only boats on the reservoir belong solely to San Francisco and the National Park Service. Hetch Hetchy Reservoir is the ONLY reservoir of its size in California that does not allow public boating.
The Taste of “Hetch Hetchy” Water
San Francisco’s water may be good, but it is not exceptional, and not even the best tasting in the Bay Area. In a 2024 double-blind taste test, designed and initiated by University of Colorado graduate students, San Francisco’s water came in last place behind East Bay MUD and Marin.

Every few years San Francisco shuts down it pipelines to its Tuolumne River supplies for maintenance and relies solely on its local reservoirs – whose water is filtered before delivery. A San Francisco Public Utilities Commission official dryly noted that customers rarely complain about the water’s taste during these shutdowns; rather they tend to complain only when they read about it in the news.
So Let’s Face It
Many who drink San Francisco’s water ignore the environment devastation caused by damming Hetch Hetchy Valley. They overlook the debacles involved in its construction and the ongoing denial of public access. They choose instead to glorify Hetch Hetchy Reservoir beyond all reason and to deify its creators.